Castrol vs. Valvoline: Which One to Buy

A vehicle’s engine has several moving parts that require constant lubrication to keep them in the best condition. Engine oil makers have been formulating engine oils to enhance engine efficiency and increase engine performance.

With so many engine oils in the market, it is confusing to pick an ideal choice. With Castrol and Valvoline, it has never been easier to determine which fluid is best for your vehicle and why.

When it comes to engine oil, there are several players in the Canadian market; this includes Castrol, Mobil, Valvoline, Petro-Canada lubricants, Pennzoil, and Royal Dutch Shell Plc, among others. However, you must choose the one that offers you a superior solution.

Castrol and Valvoline are the two most renowned brands that are highly efficient in matching the demands of all types of vehicle engines. These two top-rated lubricant brands are used in almost all repair shops and gas stations. 

So, which of the two is best? And why should you choose it over the other? In this article, we have compared the benefits of Castrol and Valvoline to help you make the buying decision.

In this article:

About Castrol

Castrol has been in the market for over a century now. They are well-known as one of the best motor oil brands. It is a premium brand with affordable pricing compared to the other competing oil brands. Castrol oil has incredibly high performance, offers good protection, and lubrication for the engine, and even has a longer life than cheaper oil brands. 

Castrol synthetic blend engine oil offers long-lasting protection to upwards of 32180 kms. This is double the life of an average, off-the-shelf synthetic oil. Castrol engine oils have been tested to have better longevity than Valvoline. Castrol is the best friction-reduction engine oil, providing excellent engine protection to deliver high performance.

About Valvoline

Valvoline is also one of the oldest engine oil brands and hence synonymous with reliability. Valvoline provides reliable engine oil solutions for medium-high temperature applications compared to Castrol, which offers good performance under a wide range of temperatures including extremely high temps. Valvoline relies on simple technologies to stay among the top choices of consumers. It is also cheaper compared to Castrol.

Castrol Vs Valvoline: Which One Is Better?

Though both oils serve the same purpose, there are some key differences between the two. These differences separate one from the other. The purpose of any lubricant oil is to protect the engine by reducing engine stress. However, the question is, who among them does the work better? To see which is more efficient, it is essential to understand the key differences between the two. Let us look at the comparison chart to understand the two most popular engine lubricant brands. 

Basis of DifferenceValvolineCastrol
Engine-wear protection
Valvoline has an anti-wear film to prevent the breakdown of engines.
Castrol offers 6X better engine wear protection than required by an updated sequence IVA Test.
PerformanceValvoline protects the vehicle’s engine from deposits and sludge
Castrol maximizes performance by protecting the engine from sludge and wear
Suitable forValvoline is effective in medium high-temperatures
Castrol is exceptionally effective at high temperatures
PropertiesIt has antioxidants that protect the oil breakdown in harsh weather
Castrol resists modern engine stress. 
TechnologyValvoline has a Dual Defense Additive Technology, that minimizes sludge and wears to keep the engine clean. 
Castrol has Fluid Titanium Technology - that reduces friction and acts as a cushion to unlock true engine performance. The Fluid Titanium Technology has a stronger performance under pressure.
LongevityValvoline offers a medium longevity
Castrol offers high longevity
PriceSlightly less in price than Castrol
Slightly high in price compared to Valvoline.

Key Difference between Castrol and Valvoline

Both Castrol and Valvoline are premium quality synthetic oils. They provide the needed lubrication to different types of vehicle engines. 


A. Excellent Engine Protection

Valvoline is good-performance engine oil that fights wear, sludge, and heat to minimize engine stress.  

Whereas in extreme weather conditions, Castrol gives extra strength to the engine and maximizes its performance. Castrol extends vehicle performance by providing extra strength to extend drain for miles and muscle strength to maintain viscosity stability under extreme conditions.


B. Advanced Anti-Wear System

Valvoline has invented 'Dual Defense Additive' technology that protects the engine from wear and tear. Castrol is scientifically built with 'Fluid Titanium' technology that offers six times better engine protection as compared to other oils. This is proved by IVA (Individual Vehicle Approval) wear tests that measure engine oil’s ability. It helps the engine reduce friction to attain maximum performance. 


C. Viscosity

Castrol and Valvoline offer a variety of viscosity grades. Castrol and Valvoline have proven to perform at different temperatures. However, under extremely high temperatures, Castrol engine oil performs better than Valvoline engine oil. 


D. Engineered with Precision

The Valvoline synthetic formula is engineered to provide safety in different weather conditions. However, Castrol has been engineered to effectively reduce metal-to-metal friction. Metal-to-metal friction happens very frequently when the driving speed of a vehicle changes. In such a situation, Castrol is a top choice. This lubricant protects the engine components from damage. It gives the best result even in harsh weather conditions. 


E. Longevity

Both Castrol and Valvoline provide better longevity than conventional engine oils. The synthetic oils offered by these brands are designed to keep the lubricating properties for a longer duration without breaking down. However, when these two engine oils are tested to compare their longevity, Castrol retains its oil properties for a longer period. 


F. Fuel Economy

Valvoline is a detergent-based formula that acts as a lubricant for the engine and a cleaner of sludge build-ups. In contrast, Castrol's titanium-based technology confirms superior performance and strength. It is easily able to adjust to different viscosity breakdowns. As a result, the engine's fuel economy and performance increase. 


G. Manufacturing Mechanism

The antioxidants present in Valvoline resist the breakdown of motor oil during harsh conditions. On the other hand, Castrol helps eliminate the formation of deposits and sludge in the engine. This allows the car to react immediately to the command.

Castrol Vs. Valvoline: Which One to Buy?

Castrol offers high performance, better longevity, maximum temperature performance, friction reduction, protects the engine from sludge and wear, and is economical. Both these popular brands have several benefits. This makes decision-making challenging. 

However, before buying Castrol or Valvoline engine oil, carefully assess the two and decide which to buy. Make sure you consider important factors rather than just the price tag. Check here to know more about your vehicle-specified engine oils.  


Articles and Guides that are written with the help of mechanics to ensure you have all the knowledge you need to make the correct purchase here at PartsAvatar.

Read all Guides & Articles


Castrol synthetic oil is an excellent choice for all types of vehicle engines. It protects the engine up to several miles effectively. This means that it is highly cost-effective. Also, Castrol Oil can be recycled, which means you utilize it multiple times.

Castrol and Valvoline are the top lubricant brands in the market. Both engine oils have their pros and cons. For example, Castrol oil is very effective even at extreme temperatures, whereas Valvoline is effective only at medium temperatures. Castrol has products that guarantee the engine's long life, courtesy of Magnatec technology.

Valvoline has been in the market for over 150 years. It has a diverse line of products. Valvoline is a high-quality lubricant that assures the efficiency of the engines.

You can mix different oil brands only if they have the exact specifications. For example, if you have Castrol 5w30 oil, you can mix it only with Valvoline 5w30 oil. This will not have any adverse impact on the performance. However, you must not mix varying oil types.

Castrol offers a wide range of lubricants, and many are the best in their respective categories in the market. Castrol EDGE full synthetic oil is the best choice for this lubricant brand. It is versatile and highly efficient. And it can be used in new as well as old vehicles.

persona image
John Framigllia
Technical Writer
Our technical writer is known for simplifying automotive parts and services. Intuitive with various vehicles and manufacturers, he knows how to simplify complicated problems.